Has Physics Destroyed Philosophy?
Fri, Dec 19 2014 02:28
| Permalink
7.30pm. Thursday January 29th 2015 at The
Victoria, 48 John Bright Street, Birmingham B1 1BN.
Philosophy is dead, Stephen Hawking argues. It has not kept
up with modern developments in science, particularly physics.
So Raymond Tallis relates in his essay Should we just shut up and calculate? Does Physics need Philosophy?
At Birmingham Salon, Tallis will explore the gulf separating science and
philosophy – the contrast between the world as we experience it and its representation
in the physical sciences.
It was not always this way. Tallis is at pains to point out
that in ancient times, the philosopher and the physicist were often one and the
same. “Let no one ignorant of geometry enter here” was reputedly inscribed at the
entrance of Plato’s Academy. From the 16th century scientific
revolution onwards, however, quantitative and empirical approaches
progressively displaced ‘armchair speculations’. While Philosophy came to a
standstill – or seemed to – science made spectacular advances that have
transformed human lives.
So what’s the problem?
Our daily lived experience and scientific theory have parted
company, Tallis says, and this is especially noticeable in relation to time. The Special Theory of Relativity sounded the death knell for ‘tensed time’ with its clearly
delineated notions of past, present and future. And yet this is a reality that
underpins the lives of everyone, including physicists. Einstein himself was
troubled by the disappearance of the ‘now’ and its meaninglessness in physics.
That the theory of relativity cannot accommodate our lived experience and the
contrast between the knowable past and the unknowable future ought to concern
us all, argues Tallis.
At the Birmingham Salon, Tallis will make the case for a philosophical
approach to complement physics in
reconciling scientific discovery with the everyday reality.
About Raymond Tallis
Professor Raymond Tallis is a philosopher, poet, novelist
and cultural critic and was until recently a physician and clinical scientist.
In autumn 2009 he was listed by the Economist's
Intelligent Life Magazine
as one of the top living polymaths in the world.
Recommended Reading
Philosophy isn't dead yet. Raymond Tallis in The Guardian, 27 May 2013
Should we just shut up
and calculate? Does Physics need Philosophy? In: Tallis, Raymond. Reflections of a metaphysical flâneur and other essays, 2013
Mistaking Mathematics
for Reality In: Tallis Raymond. EpimetheanImaginings: Philosophical and other meditations on every day light, 2014.
Comments